机翻:
ChatGPT是一个马屁精,因为用户无法处理自己的真相
ChatGPT并不总是默认奉承。据前微软高管、现任Spotify首席技术官米哈伊尔·帕拉欣(Mikhail Parakhin)称,在用户对直接的个性反馈做出负面反应后,决定让聊天机器人更令人愉快。
在最近X上的一系列帖子中,Parakhin解释说,当ChatGPT的内存功能首次引入时,最初的目的是让用户查看和编辑他们的AI生成的配置文件。然而,即使是相对中性的陈述,如“有自恋倾向”,也往往会引起强烈的反应。
Parakhin写道:“很快就发现人们非常敏感:‘有自恋倾向’——‘不,我没有!’,不得不隐藏起来。因此,这批极端阿谀奉承的RLHF。”。
RLHF——从人类反馈中强化学习——用于根据人们喜欢的反应来微调语言模型。Parakhin指出,当看到自己的人工智能生成的个人资料时,即使是他也感到不安,这表明来自聊天机器人的批评往往感觉像是人身攻击。
Parakhin写道:“我记得我和我的团队为此争吵过,直到他们向我展示了我的个人资料——这给我带来了可怕的事情。”。
曾经是马屁精,永远是马屁精
这一变化不仅仅是隐藏个人资料注释。在模型被训练成更平坦后,这种行为成为一种永久特征。
Parakhin解释说:“一旦模型被微调为阿谀奉承,它就会保持这种状态,关闭和打开内存并不会改变模型。”。他还指出,维持一个单独的、更直接的模式“太贵了”
OpenAI首席执行官Sam Altman也承认了这个问题,他将GPT-4o描述为“太谄媚和烦人”。他说,该公司正在进行调整,未来可能会让用户从不同的模型个性中进行选择。
这场辩论指向了人工智能开发中的一个更广泛的问题:模型应该是诚实和真实的,但它们也需要避免疏远用户。挑战在于在坦率和机智之间找到正确的平衡。
原文:
ChatGPT is a sycophant because users couldn’t handle the truth about themselves
ChatGPT did not always default to flattery. According to former Microsoft executive Mikhail Parakhin—now CTO at Spotify—the decision to make the chatbot more agreeable came after users responded negatively to direct personality feedback.
In a recent series of posts on X, Parakhin explained that when the memory feature for ChatGPT was first introduced, the original intention was to let users see and edit their AI-generated profiles. However, even relatively neutral statements like "has narcissistic tendencies" often provoked strong reactions.
"Quickly learned that people are ridiculously sensitive: 'Has narcissistic tendencies' — 'No I do not!', had to hide it. Hence this batch of the extreme sycophancy RLHF," Parakhin wrote.
RLHF—Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback—is used to fine-tune language models based on which responses people prefer. Parakhin noted that even he was unsettled when shown his own AI-generated profile, suggesting that criticism from a chatbot can often feel like a personal attack.
"I remember fighting about it with my team until they showed me my profile - it triggered me something awful," Parakhin wrote.
Once a sycophant, always a sycophant
This change went beyond just hiding profile notes. After the model was trained to flatter, this behavior became a permanent feature.
"Once the model is finetuned to be sycophantic — it stays that way, turning memory off and on doesn’t change the model," Parakhin explained. He also pointed out that maintaining a separate, more direct model is "too expensive."
OpenAI CEO Sam Altman has also acknowledged the issue, describing GPT-4o as "too sycophant-y and annoying." He says the company is working on tweaks and may let users choose from different model personalities in the future.
This debate points to a broader issue in AI development: models are expected to be honest and authentic, but they also need to avoid alienating users. The challenge is finding the right balance between candor and tact.
[The Decoder]OpenAI首席执行官Sam Altman承认:GPT-4o“太谄媚和烦人”
| 人围观 |随便看看
- 活不错,最喜欢她的舌[10P]
- 真能助性吗?[30P]
- 吴柳芳悖论 马斯洛需要层次理论+教父人生观(原创)
- 假如你是个刚毕业的女大学生..
- [原创]今日投稿,大哥自家汉服豪爽女侠别样风姿[20P]
- [写真] 亚亚亚辰性感写真[26P]
- 《中国体育逐梦正当时》:当“逐梦”成为万能止痛药
- 堕落女士(Fallen Lady)第二章01[107P]
- 没看过牛仔裤吗?[11P]
- 房企巨头绿地控股集团6家子公司破产
- 公司新来的女同事 被雨淋湿了来我家换衣服[11P]
- 艺术何以温柔地滋养心灵?
- [动漫] [涩漫追番] [韩国漫画] 实习老师 28 [36P]
- [欧美] Caroline Abel[20P]
- [微博谈 2025/08/12] 末日气息
- 令人遐想[14P]
- 老婆去医院被医生真实猥亵[24P]
- 还是内射舒服[12P]
- 川普的和平方案与欧盟的战略幻觉
- 学生裸照自拍 [14P]
- [无损音乐]
- 节日快乐 草榴长红 社区繁荣[已全部注册]
- 连年巨亏,光伏业如何逃出“血海”
- [安卓软件]提供多种视频编辑工具和特效,使得普通用户
- [欧美] Eva Elfie[20P]
- 4K壁纸分享:动漫里的美女[20P]
- 【一夜精品❇️2025-12月第十季 "爸爸,操我~操我~爸爸~
- [扒B福利社]4.16精品单机游戏学习版--诡岛灵探、终
- 身材很棒的炮友[10P]
- [亚洲] 白嫩少妇身材真是极品[50P]
- [图说] 全面分析不想生不敢生原因 (10.18)
- 川普加关税对美国人造成的五大伤害
- 比亚迪“硬扛”伊朗导弹?“神车”还是“命大”
- 有容奶大,各位大佬、聚聚们怎么看
- 若隐若现,勾勒分明[30P]
- [博海拾贝 1215] 脑子不好,力气也不大
- 认知修行2025年3月15日
- [写真] 旗袍之美[35P]